What is Chalk?

Chalk is under heavy development, so if any of these links are broken or if any of the information is inconsistent with the code or outdated, please open an issue so we can fix it. If you are able to fix the issue yourself, we would love your contribution!

Chalk is a library that implements the Rust trait system. The implementation is meant to be practical and usable, but also high-level enough to map easily to a full specification. It is also meant to be an independent library that can be integrated both into the main rustc compiler and also other programs and contexts.

High-level view of how chalk works

graph TD
    Query["Does `Vec<u8>` implement `Debug`?"]
    HighLevelInfo["How is the trait `Debug` declared?"]
    Response["Yes, `Vec<u8>` implements `Debug`."]
    Query --> Chalk
    HighLevelInfo --> Chalk
    Chalk --> Response

Chalk is designed to answer queries about traits, such as "Does the type Vec<u8> implement Debug"? (Yes!). It can in some cases give inference feedback, such as "Is there a unique type T such that str: AsRef<T>"? In that case, the answer might be "Yes, T = str."

To do this, it takes as input key information about a Rust program, such as:

  • For a given trait, what are its type parameters, where clauses, and associated items
  • For a given impl, what are the types that appear in the impl header
  • For a given struct, what are the types of its fields

Chalk works by converting Rust goals into logical inference rules

Internally, Chalk works by converting the Rust-specific information, like traits and impls, into logical predicates. This process is called "lowering", and you can learn more about in the Lowering to Logic and Lowering Rules) sections.

After lowering to logical predicates, Chalk then deploys a logical solver to find the answer to the original query; this solver is similar to a Prolog engine, though different in its particulars.

The following sequence diagram helps to illustrate the flow of information that occurs when Chalk is solving a particular goal. It involves three participants:

  • The host program, which might be rustc, rust-analyzer, or chalk's internal testing harness. The host program, importantly, only thinks about things in Rust terms, like traits and impls.
  • The chalk-solve crate, which converts between Rust terms and logical clauses.
  • The logic engine layer, which knows how to solve logical clauses but knows nothing specific to Rust.
  participant rustc as host program
  participant chalkSolve as chalk-solve
  participant chalkEngine as logic engine
  rustc->>chalkSolve: Does Vec[u32] implement Debug?
  chalkSolve->>chalkEngine: (Vec[u32]: Debug)?
  chalkEngine->>chalkSolve: What clauses can I use?
  chalkSolve->>rustc: What is the definition of `Debug`?<br>(via RustIrDatabase)
  rustc-->>chalkSolve: `trait Debug { .. }`<br>(a TraitDatum)
  chalkSolve->>rustc: What impls are there for Vec?
  rustc-->>chalkSolve: `impl[T]: Debug] Debug for Vec[T]`<br>(an ImplDatum)
  Note right of chalkSolve: "lowers" rust <br>declarations to logic
  chalkSolve-->>chalkEngine: (Vec[T]: Debug) :- (T: Debug)
  chalkSolve-->>chalkEngine: ... and other clauses ...
  activate chalkEngine
  Note right of chalkEngine: explores each clause<br>to see if it works
  chalkEngine-->>chalkSolve: (Vec[u32]: Debug) is provable
  deactivate chalkEngine
  chalkSolve-->>rustc: Yes, Vec[u32] implements Debug

Chalk repl

In addition to being embedded into host programs, chalk also has its own testing harness along with an associated REPL. This allows us to write unit tests that use a "Rust-like" syntax. The REPL then makes it easy to experiment and get a better feel for how chalk works. See the walkthrough for more details.